5.3: Seminar Materials

Case Study 24.1: Common but differentiated responsibilities? 


Figure. 24.1:  Severe fog and haze in the eastern Chinese city of Jiujiang. 

(c) Humphery/ Shutterstock.com 

Written into the 1992 UNFCCC - United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change - was the notion of 'common but notated responsibilities and respective capabilities. This to that although all nations had to accept responsibility for world's changing climate, it was developed (Annex 1) nations were immediately responsible because they had benefited from the industrialization which was generally regarded as the cause of the excess carbon dioxide emissions that had generated mean temperature increases (see Fig. 24.1). 

In the 1990s, the US emitted around 25 per cent of the global total but had only 4.5 per cent of the global population. Chinese figures were 14 per cent but with over 20 per cent of the world's population, while the 35 least developed nations emitted less than 1 per cent. Under the Kyoto Protocol the developed countries were expected to make emissions cuts. 

However, by 2004 it was clear that an effective post-2012 regime would have to involve the fast-growing economies of the Global South because their 'respective capabilities' had changed. In 2011, the CO2 emissions of six parties were responsible for over 70 per cent of the world total: China 29 per cent, US 16 per cent, EU 11 per cent, India 6 per cent, Russia 5 per cent, and Japan 4 per cent. It is important to remember that negotiation of a new climate agreement has occurred in the context of major structural change in the international system (see Ch. 5). 

Finding a new basis for an equitable sharing of necessary emissions reductions is fraught (full of) with problems. 

(1): Because GHGs - Greenhouse gases - have long and variable atmospheric lifetimes, from 30 up to at least 100 years, past emissions must also be taken into account. Thus developing countries can argue that most of the allowable 'carbon space' has already been taken up by the historic emissions of the old industrialized economies, and that the latter should therefore continue to take the lead in reducing emissions. 

(2): Per capita emissions still vary widely between Northern and Southern economies. Treating them in the same way cannot be either just or politically acceptable. 

(3): A major part of current Chinese emissions is the direct result of the transfer of production of goods from the US and Europe. Who, therefore, bears the responsibility? 

The 2015 Paris Agreement did not fully resolve these questions, but added the phrase 'in the light of different national circumstances' which indicated that the previous rigid distinction between Annex 1 countries and the rest was breaking down. 

The obligations placed on developed, developing, and least developed and small island states are subtly differentiated in the text of the agreement. 

  • Question 1: Should the developed countries still make larger relative emissions reduction 'contributions' even if the emerging economies are now emitting the greatest proportion of GHGs? 
  • Question 2: Would it be more just to design a future climate regime on the basis of per capita rather than total national emissions? 

Canvas link: https://canvas.kingston.ac.uk/courses/22115/pages/seminar-materials-of-week-5-2?module_item_id=75266

4 comments:

  1. Question1: Countries should make larger emission reductions even as large economies merge. As trade increases so do emissions and regulating that is vital for the environment and help avoid future problems. Question 2: No it would not be just as the regulations and restrictions that the government puts in place is responsible for the industry and people’s habits. There for it is more just to judge based on total national emissions.

    ReplyDelete
  2. [Q1]:Yes! Countries should make larger emissions so that they can avoid future problems such as global warming as the international trade is going it also increases the global warming and effects on the world globally so it would be helpful for the future if they do it now.
    [Q2:]No , it should be done internationally rather then per capita because it is an international problem and can be sorted by the total national emissions

    ReplyDelete
  3. Muhammad ali anwarMay 13, 2022 at 9:22 AM

    Developed Countries Are Responsible for 79 Percent of Historical Carbon Emissions | Center for Global Development | Ideas to Action

    ReplyDelete
  4. Muhammad ali anwarMay 13, 2022 at 9:30 AM

    Which countries contribute the most to climate change per capita (Tons)? CO2 Emissions per Capita: China: 7.38, United States: 15.52, India: 1.91, Russia: 11.44

    ReplyDelete